Saturday, April 28, 2012

The Heritability Hoax!

The apple does not fall far from the tree but no two apple trees grow the same.  For a long time, eugenists claimed that the ills of society were caused by our pedigree, socioeconomic status, and euthenics.  Their basis for such claims were simple: Look at our color and similar looks to our parents - of course it makes sense.

There is no question that there is some heritable aspects we acquire from our parents.  We know that eye, skin and hair color and consistency, have a heritable basis of between 35% and 70% because these differences are small, controlled by about twelve end genes that are easily varied.  But as you get to height, there are 100 major and a few thousand minor genes involved.  The heritability for height, therefore, drops to 16% as the candidate genes increase in number, complexity and position.

As processes becomes more complex, like intelligence and behavior, billions of genes are in play.  On such complex processes affecting the specie, the similarities completely trump the slight and small differences that occur over a hundred generations of procreation.  To illustrate, four million years ago, we broke off from chimps - with which we share 98% of our genes.  About every million years, we changed about 1/2 percent as a species.  Ten thousand years ago, there were about a million of us. Now there are 7 billion.  Our similarities, simply because of reproduction, are astounding.  We are all 99.99% identical and the similarity between our parents and parents from another part of the world are so fantastically similar that in complex matters, the "group" similarity far outweighs the slight "parental" variance.

GWAS, the genome wide association study, has proven this over and over again.  There are no functional mutations for intelligence or behavior that could vary over one or even a thousand generations.  A logical analysis confirms this.  Development of our brain, kidneys, liver, heart or nervous system are not dependent on a hundred genes, but millions upon millions, all of which work in concert.

Therefore, if you have kidney disease, MS, diabetes, or schizophrenia, it would be impossible for genes to be responsible for these localized injuries.  Damage to the kidney causes kidney disease.  Damage to the nervous system causes MS.  

The psychological/psychiatric community and popular press, for decades, recklessly overemphasized the very minimal actual role genetic inheritance and child rearing have on our outcomes.  The most fantastic child rearing does not improve your fluid (innate) intelligence.  It will only increase your crystallized (learned) intelligence by a few Intelligent Quotient points.  There is not any recognizable difference between learning from Barney or Elmo than learning from someone reading to you.

In reality, toxins in our environment are responsible for, among other things, low  intelligence and complex disorders of the brain, explosion of high blood pressure, and diabetes.  Data confirms this.  The prevalence of autistic, attention, and mental health illness has massively increased in this century so that about 13 percent of our population now has a DSM level mental disability http://www.nimh.nih.gov/statistics/3USE_MT_ADULT.shtml.  Some estimates place the actual number at 20 percent if milder forms of mental health symptoms are considered http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1273628.